Showing posts with label Closing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Closing. Show all posts

Monday, 16 December 2013

Closing the Gap - Student Feedback on my Feedback

This year I have tried to improve the feedback that I give to the students in all of my classes. I have tried to develop efficient feedback techniques to aid all of my classes. I blogged about this at the start of the year (see link). The aim has been to try to increase the impact of the feedback that I give in order to help the students close the gap between their current performance and the desired performance . I was happy with the quality of the feedback I was giving but felt that the impact of the marking and feedback could be increased. I also looked to do this in a more efficient manner.

The first page of an A/S assessment book
One of the ways I have looked to do this is by having specific assessment books for both my GCSE and A/S classes. The aim of these books is to keep all the assessed work, all the feedback and all the improvements, in one place. This allows the students to show understanding and ultimately progress and keeps the feedback in one accessible place.

The first pages of the A4 book are taken up by the students copying out their feedback and explaining how they are going to improve their answer. The parents also sign this page.

The rest of the book is taken up with assessed answers, my feedback, and then the improvements/re-drafting that the students have completed to ensure they have understood. The final part is me checking that the improvements are correct.

Feedback from my students
Last week I asked my A/S and GCSE class to complete an anonymous GoogleForm to give their feedback on the assessment books and my feedback more generally. Below is a Tagxedo of what they said:
Words that stand out from this to me are easier, good, helpful, improvements, think and useful.

Below are some comments from my GCSE students about the assessment books:

"I think it's quite good because you have all of your important work in one place and not all mixed in with the other stuff that doesn't have as much priority."

"It's easier having all of the more 'important' pieces of work being written in one book because then it's all in one place and it isn't likely to get lost; it's clear where everything is when it comes to writing targets or looking back to compare pieces of assessed work."

Lots of comments were similar to this in mention the organisational benefits and many also said how easy it was to look back over their work and targets.

Below are some comments from my A/S students about the assessment books:

"I like completing my AS work in the book as it allows me to keep it all in one place and easily look back on past questions / essays. It's also good for teacher feedback and discussions with parents over how certain tasks have gone."

"Great idea! We can keep all our work in place, see where we need to improve, do the improvements and get feedback easily."

"I like been able to keep track of all my essays and i can see improvement across the book,
However i feel getting it signed and filling out the front is a bit over the top "


My A/S students focused more on the impact of the feedback and moving forward. It seems that getting parents to sign the book has divided opinion but my reasoning behind it is to keep parents informed and ensuring that any performance is seen be all parties. I also think getting it signed increases the seriousness with which the students take the assessed work.

Moving forward
It seems that the students feel that the assessed book is worthwhile. None of the comments were completely negative about it and the vast majority were positive.

That said one reaccurring theme was obvious; the students would like more positive feedback.

"Give positive feedback as well as improvements (particular things we did well)."

"Give more positives."

In light of these comments, and others like them, I am going to increase the amount of positive remarks I give. Looking back through the books I realised that I gave out merits but did not specifically say what the students had done to earn these merits. I am obviously going to make this a New Years Resolution.

Finally, though I am pleased with the reaction from my students to the assessment books. It has made my feedback more meaningful, it has allowed the students to show how they have acted upon the feedback and finally it has been organisationally efficient.

A final word from one of my A/S students:

"I don't really have any improvements, it's the best feedback I receive on homework."


Sunday, 15 September 2013

Closing the Gap - developing efficient feedback techniques

Towards the end of last term and at the start of this I have been looking to develop my strategies for ensuring students make the most of their feedback and hopefully therefore make the most progress.

Firstly, I think it's important to say that none of the principles I am discussing here are new to my practice. All of the things I have done before. What I am really talking about here is ways of systematising what I do to make sure that as many students as possible can successfully close the gap between where they are and where they want to be.

One of the big issues with this is time and efficiency. This is especially true in my lower school teaching. If I am honest I am always going to make sure my priorities (GCSE and A-Level) are taken care of. That is partly because I don't feel that I have to be as efficient at closing the gap with my GCSE and A-Level classes as I do with my lower school classes because of the following reasons:
• My GCSE/A-Level classes are smaller and I see them more often than my lower school classes.
• My GCSE/A-Level students are older so can work more independently whilst I am speaking 1-1 with other students.
• My GCSE/A-Level classes are probably more assessed and can therefore remember their feedback more often.
• If students in my GCSE/A-Level classes are struggling it is much more feasible to bring them back on a lunchtime or after school to work 1-1.
• My GCSE/A-Level students are motivated by a real exam so are much more likely to want to improve.

So what I am setting out to do this year is  to develop my teaching so that I ensure more students close the gap. But I am aiming to do it in a way that is efficient enough so that all my students can do this more effectively, not just my examined classes.

I am going to base my attempts to close the gap around the following three principles. I do not believe these are groundbreaking in any way but I do believe they will help all my students to close the gap.

1) All feedback must be acted on.
I have always asked all my students to show that they have understood assessment feedback. Whether it is year 7 completing a SHP analysis of the 'Mystery of the Skeletons' or my A2 personal study students, all have had to act on the feedback. 

Having given students a target for their work they then had to do something to show me they had understood it. If a year 7 hadn't included enough facts and figures to back up their arguments for example, then they had to find five facts they hadn't included and add them to their work.

What I am doing this year is to ask all my students to act on all their targets no matter the significance is the work. My students have to write where they have worked on this under the target so that I can quickly see when looking through their books. For some pieces of work the students may be able to add to the original. For others they would have to do something on another page. I have asked my students to number the pages of their books to make it even easier for me to find.

At the start of a lesson I will give the students 5-10 minutes to look at my marking and to close the gap. I am giving lesson time to show the importance of this task, even with year 8, where I only see them once a week, I am going to force myself to ensure that I make time for this.

I am then be able to quickly scan through this when I next see their books. I have ordered a stamp which says "@Westylish says "Feedback acted on! Well Done!"" Obviously, if they have still not understood I will then be able to bear that in mind for that round of marking.

2) All feedback must inform.
At the start of a new piece of work all my students must write a previous target that they are going to apply to this particular piece of work. Obviously, some targets may be related to a certain type of piece of work and may not apply to the new piece. Students will have a choice and must write the target and what they are going to do in this piece of work to make sure they don't get the same target written down. With my lower school classes I will use a Kagan structure to share what has been written.

3) All students must reflect on their work before handing it in.
The idea for this came to me from one of my A/S students last year. At the end of every assessed piece of work he wrote down what I had told him to do last time and how he believed he had managed to achieve those targets on this piece of work.

The way he did it was to sort of have a bit of a 'pop' at me. As if to say "well you said this last time and look I've done it now, so you better give me a higher mark!"

I was really impressed with this and I am going to make all my students do it inevery  year. When I tried it for the first time with my GCSE class quite a number of students were forced to write "last time you told me to do this and well, I still haven't done it. But I will do next time." A few students decided to take their work home and hand it in tomorrow in light of this 'revelation'.

This last example shows how important it is to force students to return to their targets. 

To finish
All three of these strategies are basic. But what I am trying to stop is the advice and feedback I give being wasted with students slipping through the net and not closing the gap.

I believe that all of these three strategies can be adopted without significantly adding to my workload even with the 90 or so year 7's I see a week. 

I do believe that they will take up some lesson time but what's the point in marking taking up my time if the students do not get the real benefit out of it?

I hope that by systematising my teaching in this way far fewer students will slip through the net and far more will be able to close the gap.